Roadrunner Blogs | The Contentious Consensus
Apr 16.09
The Top 20 Most Underrated Albums of All Time! (we think...)

As you can guess this sparked heavy debate, and some of us didn't even want to sign off on the final list, but through it all what we came up with democratically is as follows.
- 1. Faith No More - "Angel Dust"
- 2. Pantera - "The Great Southern Trendkill"
- 3. Fear Factory - "Soul of a New Machine"
- 4. Megadeth - "Youthanasia"
- 5. Far - "Water & Solutions"
- 6. Death - "Symbolic"
- 7. Mr. Bungle - "California"
- 8. Tool - "Opiate"
- 9. Type O Negative - "Origin of the Feces"
- 10. St. Vitus - "V"
- 11. Wintersun - "Wintersun"
- 12. Opeth - "Still Life"
- 13. Gojira - "From Mars to Sirius"
- 14. Only Living Witness - "Prone Mortal Form"
- 15. All That Remains - "This Darkened Heart"
- 16. Aerosmith - "Rocks"
- 17. Bad Religion - "Recipe for Hate"
- 18. Starkweather - "Murder in Technicolor"
- 19. Bloodbath - "Resurrection Through Carnage"
- 20. Pink Floyd - "Pulse"
Some of the people involved with writing this list disagree to some extent the order of the list, or even some bands that are on it. We want to see what your list looks like. Pick your top 20 UNDERRATED albums of all time and post it in this news post and we'll send a whole bunch of you some free shit! Make sure your email address is correct so we can contact you!
Special thanks to the people who helped out creating this list, Amy Sciarretto, Mike Gitter, Sam Roon, Heff and Justin D'Angelo.

COMMENTS
09.16.2009 Cynonyte wrote...
Realm: Suiciety
Carcass: Swansong
Tourniquet: Pathogenic Ocular Dissonance
Annacrusis: Screams and Whispers
Brutality: In Mourning
Wrathchild America: 3-D
Brutal Truth: Extreme Conditions....
Confessor: Condemned
Forbidden: Twisted Into Form
King Diamond: Conspiracy
Hypocrisy: Hyprocrisy
Sentenced: North From Here
Believer: Dimensions
Vio-Lence: Opressing the Masses
Warrior Soul: Last Decade Dead Century
I could go on.. but my brain hurts!!
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
08.14.2009 esteban coloma wrote...
2.RAMMSTEIN- mutter
3.SUICIDAL TENDENCIES- prime cuts
4.STRAPPING YOUNG LAD- strapping young lad
5.STONE SOUR- stone sour
6.ALICE IN CHAINS- unplugged
7.BLOODSIMPLE- red harvest
8.CRO MAGS- best wishes
9.D.R.I.- full speed ahead
10.EARTH CRISIS- silther
11.FAITH NO MORE- angel dust
12.FEAR FACTORY- archetype
13.HATESPHERE- to the nines
14.KsE- alive or just breathing
15.MACHINE HEAD- the blackening
16.MISFITS- cuts from the crypt
17.NIN- with teeth
18.OBITUARY- frozen in time
19.PROBOT- probot
20.VISION OF DISORDER- fom bliss to devastation
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
08.12.2009 skinculture wrote...
2- SEPULTURA - Chaos AD
3- SLAYER - Seasons in the Abyss
4- MACHINE HEAD - More Thing Change
5- PANTERA - Cowboys from Hell
6- WHITE ZOMBIE - La Sexorcisto: Devil Music
7- FEAR FACTORY - Demanufacture
8- KREATOR - Extreme Aggression
9- ANTHRAX - In The Man
10-NUCLEAR ASSAULT - Game over
11-SOD - Storm Troopers Of Death
12-TESTAMENT - The New Order
13-MEGADETH - Rust in Peace
14-JUDAS PRIEST - Painkiller
15-FAITH NO MORE - Real Thing
16-MESHUGGAH - None
17-BIOHAZARD - State Of The World Address
18-KORN - Untochables
19-SLIPKNOT - Slipknot
20-LAMB OF GOD - Sacrament
These are the bands and albums that changed generations of Metal music in the world.
Rate This Comment
1 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
08.11.2009 skinculture wrote...
Listen in Official signmeto Roadrunner Records:SKIN CULTURE from Brazil.
The band Metal / Experimental SKIN CULTURE has become without doubt one of the leading names of the new generation of the Brazilian scene of heavy rock.
The group resurfaces from the ashes of his first and successful album "HUMANGEDOM" (2005), which reached the incredible mark of 100,000 CDs sold over in more than 40 countries, drawing the attention of global media specialist as KERRANG and ALFA OMEGA (Spain) , ROCK BRIGADE (Brazil), METAL MATANZA (Argentina) and HEAVY METAL Magazine (Romania).
In june 2009 the SKIN CULTURE launch its new, more and powerful álbum "THE EARTH SPITS", which was mixed by the hands of American producer Tim LauD (SOULFLY / CAVALERA CONSPIRACY / PRIMER 55 / SIX FEET UNDER) among other big names ...with plus special guest Glenny Telford (SKINLAB) and Nacho Mingone and Daniel Zseitner (BRUTHAL 6) from Argentina.
The SKIN CULTURE bring in their luggage into the headliner side of SEPULTURA at MONSTER OF METAL festival 2007 in Buenos Aires Argentina, the guest participation and support in all the concerts of American band P.O.D. (Payable On Death) in Brazil in 2008 and the opening of all the concerts of the American bands ILL NINO and HYRO DA HERO in South America in june 2009.
The band SKIN CULTURE now prepares to reaching more flights between its first American tour.
www.myspace.com/skinculturetribal
Rate This Comment
1 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
05.16.2009 Blair Lauver wrote...
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
05.11.2009 TREVOR REVERDITTO wrote...
2. Black Sabbath- Born Again
3. Doctor Butcher
4.Crimson Glory-Astronimica
5.Aerosmith- Rock in a Hard Place
6.Black Sabbath - Dehumanizer
7.Leatherwolf-World Asylum
8.Warrior- Ancient Future
9.Immpletteri-pedal to the metal
10.Chris Caffery- pins and needles
11.Savatage- Jesus Saves
12.Aerosmith-Rocks
13.Flotsam & jetsam- My God
14.Suicidal Tendencies-The Art of Rebellion
15.Lizzy Borden- menace to Society
16.Nevermore-Dreaming Neon Black
17.Sanctuary- into the mirror black
18.Metal church-Hanging in the balance
19.Badlands
20.Malice- in the beginning
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
05.07.2009 Sharon Steger wrote...
1.metallica...and justice for all.
2.lamb of god ashes of the wake
3.pantera far beyond driven
4.trivium ember to inferno
5.orgy candyass
6.orgy vapor transmission
7.orgy punk statik paranoia
8.sepultura beneath the remains
9.fear factory soul of a new machine
10.slayer seasons in the abyss
11.morbid angel domination
12.mudvayne l.d.50
13.marilyn manson eat me drink me
14.dimmu borgir stormblast
15.arch enemy doomsday machine
16.soulfly prophecy
17.coal chamber chamber music
18.murderdolls beyond the valley of the murderdolls
19.burn the priest
20.chimaira the impossibility of reason
thank you for ur time xoxo
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
05.03.2009 Robert Mendez wrote...
1.The Mars Volta- De-loused in the Comatorium
2.At The Drive-in- Relationship in Command
3.Static X- Wisconsin Death Trip
4.System of a down- Self titled
5.Opeth- Damnation
6.Cradle of filth- Damnation and a Day
7.Demon Hunter- Self Titled
8.Adema- Self titled
9.Deftones- Saturday Night Wrist
10.In Flames- Whoracle
11.Lamb Of god- New American Gospel
12.Avenged Sevenfold- Waken The Fallen
13.Underoath- Define The Great Line
14.Tool- Opiate
15.Coheed and Cambria- In Keeping Secrets Of Silent Earth 3
16.Dredg- El Cielo
17.Vehemence- God Was Created
18.Cannibal Corpse- Eaten Back To Life
19.Korn- life is peachy
20.Necrophagist- Epitaph
Honorable mentions:
Korn- Untitled
Cannibal Corpse- The Wretched Spawn
Mortician- House By the cemetery
The Faceless- Planetary Duality
Slipknot- iowa
Abigail Williams- In The Shadow of a Thousand Suns
Opeth- Still life
Mudvayne- The End of all Things To Come
Tool- Undertow
Killswitch Engage- Alive or Just Breathing
All That Remains- This Darkened heart
Deftones- Around The Fur
Dir en Grey- Vulgar
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
05.03.2009 Archie Chaffin wrote...
1 Pantera-The Great Southern Trendkill
2 Tool-Opiate
3 All That Remains-This Darkened Heart
4 Disturbed-Believe
5 Avenged Sevenfold-City of Evil
6 Mastodon-Leviathan
7 Hellyeah-Hellyeah
8 In flames-Clayman
9 Buckcherry-15(I'm adding this because I think the instrumentals in the album are underrated like crazy bitch the lyrics suck but the guitar is cool.)
10 Roadrunner United: The All-Star Sessions
11 Dimmu Borgir - In Sorte Diaboli
12 Van Halen-Van Halen II
13 Lamb of God-New American Gospel
14 In Flames-Whoracle
15 Dethklok-The Dethalbum (Brendon Small and Gene Hoglan are pretty amazing musicians)
16 Tenacious D-Tenacious D
17 5FDP-The Way of the Fist
18 CoB-Hatebreeder
19 Firewind-Allegiance
20 Black Label Society-Shot to Hell
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT
04.26.2009 William Panschar wrote...
1. Birds of Fire, by The Mahavishnu Orchestra
2. Train of Thought, by Dream Theater
3. Scenes form a Memory, by Dream Theater
4. Stormwatch, by Jethro Tull
5. In A Glass House, by Gentle Giant
6. Noisy Nights, by UZEB
7. Turbulent Indigo, by Joni Mitchell
8. Music Spoken Here, by John McLaughlin
9. Electric Dreams, by John McLaughlin
10. Livestock, by Roy Buchanan
11. The Grand Wazoo, by Frank Zappa
12. Manassas, by Stephen Stills
13. Mr. Gone, by Weather Report
14. Free Hand, by Gentle Giant
15. Mar-Y-Sol Festival, various artists
16. Mountain in the Clouds, by Miroslav Vitous
17. Dregs of the Earth, by Dixie Dregs
18. The Flat Earth, by Thomas Dolby
19. Aliens Ate My Buick, by Thomas Dolby
20. Observations And, by Billy Cobham's Glass Menagerie
Thanks for this opportunity,
Bill
wpanschar@hotmail.com
Rate This Comment
0 0REPLIES TO THIS COMMENT